• Subscribe
  • E-Newsletter
  • Media Kit
  • Contact Us
  • Login
Community Rec
  • Topics
    • Community
    • Facility Development
    • Programming
    • Operations
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
    • Subscribe
    • E-Newsletter
    • Media Kit
    • Contact Us
  • On-Demand
  • Continuing Education
    • Community Rec Leadership Summit
    • Webinars
    • Pickleball Innovators
  • Supplier Insights
    • Brand Voice
    • Supplier News
    • Supplier Voice
    • Case Studies
  • Podcast
  • Buyer’s Guide
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Community
    • Facility Development
    • Programming
    • Operations
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
    • Subscribe
    • E-Newsletter
    • Media Kit
    • Contact Us
  • On-Demand
  • Continuing Education
    • Community Rec Leadership Summit
    • Webinars
    • Pickleball Innovators
  • Supplier Insights
    • Brand Voice
    • Supplier News
    • Supplier Voice
    • Case Studies
  • Podcast
  • Buyer’s Guide
No Result
View All Result
Community Rec
No Result
View All Result
Home In Print Ask The Expert

Member Retention Q&A with Nicole Hagemeyer

Brittany Howard by Brittany Howard
July 7, 2023
in Ask The Expert, In Print, Operations & Facilities
0
member retention
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

In the 2023 July/August issue, we spoke with Nicole Hagemeyer, the general manager of fitness and membership at JCC Indianapolis, about member retention.

Can you share about the member retention strategy at JCC Indianapolis? 

We’ve learned if you engage a member in three activities you will double the retention rate, so we start before they even join. First, we lead them on a tour of our facility to showcase all the great offerings and offer a free, one-week trial membership. If they join at the end of the tour or membership trial, we have them complete an interest card and give them our membership folder that contains all upcoming program offerings and information. The interest card allows us to tailor their welcome letter to be more specific to the programs and offerings they are interested in. Then, we invite them to join us for a free fitness center orientation with a personal trainer and a free trial to Group X classes to further help them find their interests and feel welcome. Our biggest success, however, is the people who serve in our various departments. Their welcoming attitudes, friendly smiles and dedication to what they do is what brings our members back.

What retention challenges has the JCC experienced? 

We currently have an overall retention rate of 83% but that didn’t come without changes. We’ve been working to increase our young adult and family membership categories over the past year by taking a deep look at our program offerings and ensuring we have something for everyone. We’ve slowly been bringing back youth sports and other group programs that were paused due to COVID-19. When staffing proved to be difficult, we pivoted and began running these programs with third-party providers. We offer the space and handle registration, and the third-party providers manage the staffing and programming. Of course, we ensure our new providers line up with our goals, vision and values before bringing their offerings to the J. I’m happy to share the added program offerings have brought in additional revenue and members and allow us to focus more on member experience.

How do you coach staff on conversations around membership? 

Our membership desk associates are the first and last impression we make on our members with each visit. We spend a lot of time onboarding new staff and having them shadow seasoned staff. They also receive a manual for reference and to guide them through the day-to-day policies and procedures. Much of their role is situational so we do our best to set them up for success. Unfortunately, one part of the role at the membership desk is fielding complaints. People often listen to respond rather than listen to understand. Listening to reply isn’t really paying attention to what someone is saying — it’s listening while already thinking of your reply. While staff can’t fix every problem, their ability to listen often defuses the situation as most people simply just want to be heard. 

Stay up to date on industry trends, best practices, news and more.

Tags: community recreationJCC IndianapolisJuly/August 2023member retentionNicole Hagemeyerretention
Previous Post

Inside the Carol Van Andel Healthy Living Center

Next Post

Preserving Trust with Praesidium

Brittany Howard

Brittany Howard

Brittany is the editor of Community Rec Magazine. Reach her at brittany@peakemedia.com.

Related Posts

AI
Column

AI Policy as a Path to Innovation: A Human-First Approach

June 25, 2025
AI for community recreation
Marketing & Sales

Beyond Buzzwords: How ROR Helps Rec Centers Harness AI for Community Impact

June 18, 2025
Data
Column

Making Data Human: Teaching Your Team to Use Metrics That Motivate

June 18, 2025
YMCA of Metropolitan Chicago
Leadership

YMCA of Metropolitan Chicago Names Adam Alonso as Next President and CEO

June 10, 2025
Missoula Family YMCA
Cover Story

Missoula Family YMCA: Immeasurable Spirit

May 21, 2025
YMCA of Greater Boston
Ask The Expert

Q&A on the Healthy Habits Program at the YMCA of Greater Boston

May 21, 2025
Next Post
Praesidium

Preserving Trust with Praesidium

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Exposure Guide + Media Kit

May/June 2025 Issue

Get Updates in your inbox

Stay up to date on industry trends, best practices, news and more.

Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn

Contact us at info@communityrecmag.com

  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • E-Newsletter
  • Media Kit
  • Contact Us

The Current Issue

The Latest from CO

  • Tour the Evelyn Rubenstein JCC Houston
  • Announcing the YMCA of the Jersey Shore: New Name, Same Mission
  • Stevens Point Area YMCA Building New Location Thanks to Grassroots Efforts
  • AI Policy as a Path to Innovation: A Human-First Approach

© 2025 Community Rec Magazine. Published by Peake Media.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Community
    • Facility Development
    • Programming
    • Operations
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
    • Subscribe
    • E-Newsletter
    • Media Kit
    • Contact Us
  • On-Demand
  • Continuing Education
    • Community Rec Leadership Summit
    • Webinars
    • Pickleball Innovators
  • Supplier Insights
    • Brand Voice
    • Supplier News
    • Supplier Voice
    • Case Studies
  • Podcast
  • Buyer’s Guide

© 2025 Community Rec Magazine. Published by Peake Media.